The retail environment is undergoing a seismic transition as firms increasingly sell direct to consumers instead of through multiple channels. However, the DTC revolution might be slowing down, which is a major issue for those who are banking on its success.
This year has undoubtedly been very challenging for advertisers and brands alike. Snowe was purchased. The same goes for The Inside and Maker & Son. More than 200 people were laid off by Article. Interior Define is experiencing major problems, and its future is questionable. Dims folded unexpectedly. And those are just the businesses that made headlines; many direct-to-consumer darlings are quietly looking for a way out.
How did this happen?
The pandemic, as everyone knows, skyrocketed demand for household products.
Consider the situation in March of 2020, for instance, it made sense to drastically reduce inventory stocks and reduce production orders when the world came to a grinding halt and the stock market plummeted. A few months later, businesses were forced to scramble to refill their digital shelves due to the abrupt increase in demand for home products. However, shipping containers were four or five times as expensive by that point, raw materials were scarce, and manufacturers all around the world were raising prices.
This confluence of circumstances put DTC brands in a bind. If they raised product pricing to meet growing costs, they would be equally expensive, if not considerably more, than the luxury manufacturers they intended to replace. However, failing to do so meant generating significantly less margin or possibly losing revenue on every purchase. In the event that they could even manufacture the goods.
What were once important advantages for DTC businesses become drawbacks almost instantly. Reducing margins to the bone allowed them to bypass retailers as well as provide value to customers—but when suppliers hiked prices, there was no cushion. Concentrating on a specific product had granted them laser-like marketing skills, but they had nothing whatsoever to fall back on if it couldn't be manufactured commercially.
When opposed to slow-moving traditional manufacturers and merchants, DTC companies were formerly acclaimed for their effectiveness and adaptability. However, when the crisis struck, they had very little sway with the transportation and manufacturing industries. While the Walmarts and Williams-Sonomas of the world could use their scale to negotiate better deals at every stage of the supply chain, direct-to-consumer (DTC) companies were frequently forced to wait in line for a chance to pay progressively high rates.
For all of these factors, even though 2020 and 2021 experienced exceptional increases in raw sales, DTC businesses were finding it increasingly difficult to operate economically. Things became much worse when, in early 2022, the retail market for home goods started to collapse. As a result, incoming funds dried up.
The turning of the DTC tide started on a specific date: April 26, 2021, the day Apple released iOS 14.5, the latest version of its mobile operating system. Now normally, software changes do not jeopardize company models, but this one did. The upgrade mandated that iPhone applications provide users with the choice to decline being tracked for marketing purposes as part of a larger effort on the part of the tech giant to prioritize privacy.
What appears to be a modest technical modification made a huge impact. Up until that point, Facebook's and subsequently Instagram's effective ad system had been the foundation of the direct-to-consumer economy. If you wanted to sell a DTC beauty product, you could utilize social media marketing engines to target narrow, surprisingly specific groups. When the great majority of users began to opt out of monitoring, micro-targeting has become far less effective.
The shift impacted the whole e-commerce sector, but it was especially harsh for DTC companies. Their relentless reliance on social media as a sales channel became a huge problem when the market shifted. Instagram and Facebook marketing were not just one expenditure among many for most DTC companies, but the single largest line item on their budget. Compensating for the shift required spending tens of thousands, if not hundreds of thousands, of dollars more just to attain equivalence.
The fact that direct-to-consumer businesses often target mobile users who are more likely to utilize Apple products made the shift all the more impactful. It was as if someone had upped the rent and quadrupled the utilities at the same time, further eroding the already tight margins.
DigiCom’s Solution Around The Impact Of Loss in Tracking
Apple's iOS 14 created a buzz in the market even before launching for not all right reasons. Customers, advertising agencies, and businesses all around the world were looking forward to the announcement of the new operating system, but the announcement didn’t come without some friction to advertisers. Since the rollout, many advertisers are seeing a negative impact on advertising platforms and aren’t sure how to account for it. Here’s what you need to know:
Almost every advertiser on Facebook is starting to see a drop in attribution causing performance to look worse than it is.
Advertisers have to readjust their CPA targets or their actualized data within their ad platforms to account for any attribution loss that is currently taking place.
Advertisers with budgets less than $10K a month will see a lot of volatility as adoption increases where conversions aren’t registering in the ad platforms. This doesn’t mean conversions aren’t happening, we’re just not tracking them.
Advertisers with higher price points or products/services which need longer consideration will see a higher attribution loss Vs advertisers that typically have purchases right away.
We recommend looking at GA, shopify, and total business as your leading indicators for performance. For example, if you are seeing consistent GA or total business performance in terms of CPA/ROAS, but a lower conversions on the platforms, then test scaling to see that performance holds up in terms of divergence and conversion ratio on the backend.
Struggling to generate a profit is common when it comes to DTC businesses. Many were never profitable on a sustained basis. However, at the height of the direct-to-consumer concept, profitability was secondary to expansion. Many DTC businesses were established during a golden period of venture capital, when the market was awash with cash and visionary entrepreneurs were so sought after that venture capitals would fight fiercely to issue them checks.
Then, in 2021, when it became evident that inflation was not merely a passing trend and that the U.S. economy was probably on the verge of entering a recession, the venture capital industry's mentality shifted. Unexpectedly, venture capitalists began asking more probing questions of the firms they had invested in. Unit economics became as crucial as "growth hacking," and the purse strings began to tighten. 2022 saw the greatest reduction in venture capital financing in twenty years. The turmoil of the pandemic, along with Apple's privacy policies, left DTC companies in a lurch. They turned to the same investors who had supported their rise for assistance but were met with hostility. With no other options available, the DTC founders started searching for a rapid escape or, in the absence of that, decided to close down and move forward
DigiCom’s Solution Around DTC Economics In A Tighter Market
With money drying up, brands are focusing more on efficiency, improving their run rates and working to turn a profit. It’s now more important than ever for brands to ensure that strong creatives continue to drive high CTRs with conversion rates improving on the backend.
We’re helping brands overcome these challenges by leveraging our creative studio to design and develop ads and test through numerous landing pages to improve top and bottom funnel metrics. We’re continuing to drive paid media but have changed our overall distribution strategy to include direct-to-site, influencer marketing and content marketing. This helps us provide brand awareness, education, 3rd party validation to help drive performance for our partners ultimately driving down CAC.
This leaves us with a very obvious question, what comes next?
Without a doubt, there are some exemptions, several DTC businesses have managed to survive the crisis and become stronger. In the face of a crumbling global supply chain, the capacity to manufacture in the United States, once viewed as a costly expense, is a significant asset. The commercial experience was also very beneficial. For instance, in 2014, Parachute debuted as a disruptor of bedding. But because it had eight years to develop into a strong multichannel brand, the firm had more leeway than, say, a bedding company that was launched in 2019.
With a few notable exceptions, 2022 was a difficult year for DTC home brands, and 2023 will most likely be the same. Despite the fact that the supply chain has calmed down and firms have developed creative marketing strategies, the slow-rolling economic crisis is likely to force more DTC businesses to close or sell than debut or prosper.
What should we make of the DTC's demise from fame? Many people will express schadenfreude in celebrating the death of potential disruptors. It's not difficult to comprehend why established businesses that have profitably sold plates for 80 years feel irritated when a twenty-something former marketing executive shows along and talks of disrupting the plate market.
DTC brands have somehow managed to add significant value and excitement to an industry that had become rigid and boring. Who would have guessed in 2005 that you could establish a mattress brand that would make young people feel something? DTC entrepreneurs revived the market for home products using a mix of marketing expertise, inexpensive capital, a newly available global supply chain, and pure entrepreneurial tenacity.
Furthermore, there will be a significant rebundling in the second DTC period, just as there was in the first, when various goods were unbundled into standalone businesses. The number of holding corporations that focus on purchasing and simplifying DTC businesses has already grown significantly. They might attempt to wring profitability out of formerly cash-draining firms by utilizing economies of scale and centralizing processes. The first DTC era was focused on branding and expansion; the second will be focused on cash flow and operational efficiency.
Want To Grow Your DTC Brand, Contact Us!
We at DigiCom are obsessive data-driven marketers pulling from multi-disciplinary strategies to unlock scale. We buy media across all platforms and placements and provide creative solutions alongside content creation, and conversion rate optimizations. We pride ourselves on your successes and will stop at nothing to help you grow.